When Family Loyalties Clash – The Dog Problem

Woman sniffling while a man holds a dog up in the background. Sick. Couple.

In a quiet suburban neighborhood, where life usually follows predictable patterns, a storm was brewing in the household of a loving father, his teenage son, and his pregnant wife. The center of this storm was a gentle giant of a dog, whose very presence had become the subject of a heart-wrenching debate.

The Backstory

When the original poster’s (OP) son was eight, they welcomed a dog into their lives. This dog, a mix of Great Dane and an unknown breed, quickly became the young boy’s best friend. The bond was especially significant as the son had recently lost his mother.

The dog became a source of comfort and companionship, with the son taking on most of the responsibilities of care.

The Pregnancy and the Problem

Fast forward a few years, and OP’s wife is 12 weeks pregnant. However, with the pregnancy came a sudden and inexplicable fear of the dog. She began avoiding the canine, covering her stomach protectively whenever he was near, and reacting anxiously to his every move.

This culminated in her expressing a desire to re-home the dog, citing fears of the dog potentially jumping on her and harming the unborn baby.

OP was taken aback. The dog had been trained from a young age not to jump or run into people, especially given its potential to grow into a large size due to its Great Dane heritage. The dog had never shown any aggressive behavior towards the wife or anyone else.

Wife’s Irrational Anxiety – Or Not…

The wife’s concerns weren’t solely about the dog’s potential actions. She emphasized that her anxiety, whether rational or not, was detrimental to her health and, by extension, the baby’s well-being. She felt that for her safety and the baby’s, the dog needed to be elsewhere.

OP was torn. On one hand, he understood the importance of ensuring his wife’s comfort during her pregnancy. On the other, he couldn’t fathom breaking his son’s heart by taking away his beloved pet, especially given the significant emotional role the dog played in the boy’s life.

Emotional Tug-of-War

The situation was more than just a debate about a dog’s place in the home; it was a reflection of the emotional complexities that arise in blended families. The son, having lost his mother at a tender age, found solace in the dog.

This canine companion filled a void, offering unconditional love and stability during a tumultuous time. The bond was so profound that OP even mused, “Sometimes I think he loves the dog more than me!”

On the other side of the spectrum was the pregnant wife, navigating the rollercoaster of hormones, emotions, and the impending responsibility of bringing a new life into the world. Her fears, while deemed irrational by OP, were real to her.

The looming presence of a large dog, combined with her heightened state of anxiety, painted a picture of potential danger in her mind.

Online Opinions

irate_anatid pointed out, “You’re prioritizing your son over your pregnant wife’s irrational fear. I think it might smooth things over if you’re open to considering reasonable measures to allay her fears, though.”

kykiwibear expressed strong sentiments, saying, “If you gave away my dog for that, I’d never forgive you. She is being dramatic. You’re in for a very long pregnancy.”

This user’s passionate response highlights how giving away the dog can cause lasting damage to OP’s relationship with his son.

A comment by Due-Cause6095 advised, “Don’t you dare give away your son’s dog. He didn’t ask for you to remarry and have a new child. Your son will never forgive you, or your new wife, if you allow her to continue to push this topic. She needs to actively work on coping with her anxiety. May I suggest therapy?

Moreover, some people like papa_pockets feared for the dog’s safety in saying, “I would microchip the dog, if you haven’t already. Make sure info is up to date, and see if she will seek counseling/compromise. Your kid needs his dog.”

The concern for OP’s wife’s mental state was also highlighted by MuchPreferPets, “Your wife is having irrational anxiety… but irrational people do crazy stuff and it would be very, very easy for her to get rid of the dog while you & your son aren’t there.

TeeKaye28 echoed concerns about the dog’s safety, advising, “And make sure the dog is microchipped. Just in case the dog gets out accidentally.”

Some people were very straightforward with their comments about the whole situation.

MistressLiliana opined, “Animals are lifetime responsibilities. Pawning them off because she got pregnant would be a ***ty thing to do.

Loyalties, Love, and a Loyal Dog

In suburbia, a family found themselves at a crossroads, with a loyal dog at the epicenter of their emotional whirlwind. The father, torn between his son’s profound attachment to the dog and his pregnant wife’s newfound anxieties, sought the wisdom of the online community.

This story is a clear reminder that some problems might not come with a straight solution. So, make sure to listen to all sides and make balanced decisions, not made in haste.

What do you think? Do You think the OP of this social media post was wrong? Let us know in the comments.

Featured Image Credit: AndrewLozovyi /Depositphotos.com.

This article was originally published on Ash & Pri.

Like our content? Be sure to follow us.

DISCLOSURE: The post may contain affiliate links, which means that I may receive a small commission if you make a purchase using these links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. You can read our affiliate disclosure in our privacy policy. This site is not intending to provide financial advice. This is for entertainment only.

Pri Kingston

Ash & Pri are the Founders of AshandPri.com and have spent the last decade building their way towards financial freedom and a lifetime of memories. Having successfully achieved their early retirement goal in under 10 years, they look forward to sharing their financial sense with like-minded people. Read more about Ash & Pri in the 'About Us' section.