The Wrist-Slap Debate – Navigating Expectations of Caregiving Within Family Dynamics

Senior woman in hospital bed

A recent social media discussion brings forth a thought-provoking topic: caregiving responsibilities within families and how gender roles can influence these dynamics.

The original poster (OP), a 19-year-old daughter, begins by sharing how she was faced with a challenging decision. OP shares that her mother was scheduled to undergo right wrist surgery and was counting on her daughter to provide care during the recovery phase.

The tasks involved were intimate and personal, from assisting with bathing to aiding her mother after using the restroom, despite her mother having a healthy left arm. These requests pushed against OP’s comfort zone, and she candidly expressed her reservations.

OP suggested that a professional caregiver can be hired or the mother can ask her husband for help. OP’s unease wasn’t solely about the tasks themselves; it also stemmed from the societal expectations linked to her gender. OP mentioned feeling uncomfortable with the assumption that, as a daughter, she was obligated to be her mother’s caretaker.

This broader issue of traditional gender roles and their impact on family dynamics became a central theme in the ensuing discussion. OP shared that she did not want to hurt her mother but this request from the mother crossed her boundaries.

Perplexed, OP turns to the online community to seek advice if she did something wrong.

When Helping Family Becomes Complicated

This social media post, which boasts a medley of opinions, highlights a wide array of perspectives on the matter.

One of the earliest commenters, dreamerindogpatch, shared a personal anecdote that appeared to align with OP’s perspective. The user recounted their experience of navigating self-care after breaking their wrist. The user pointed out that despite their compromised situation, they managed to maintain their independence in daily tasks such as showering, dressing, and even hygiene.

Another commenter, silvermanedwino, showcased the resilience of the human spirit by sharing their triumph over self-care after a total hip replacement.

“Took care of myself after a total hip replacement. Wrist would be easy.”

The user’s comment, albeit brief, emphasizes the notion that resilience is innate within us, and caregivers need not always fit the stereotypical mold.

The user, Happy_to_be suggested a plausible solution that could serve both OP as well as her mother.

“Tell her to start practicing wiping with her other hand now.”

This comment highlights a vital aspect, preparation and adaptability, key factors in maintaining one’s independence.

NoReveal6677 delved into the psychological dynamics at play. This user shed light on the potential manipulation embedded within such expectations. The user labeled the situation as a “weird power move,” implying that the mother might be subtly attempting to establish an ongoing caregiver role for her daughter, OP. This perspective opens the door to questioning motives and intentions within family dynamics.

Lastly, GothicGingerbread shared a perspective that underscores the practicality of the situation.

The user commented that the expectation of caregiving might have been more understandable if the mother’s surgery involved both wrists or resulted in complete immobilization.

“I’d be more willing to see it that way if the mom only had one arm, or if she were having surgery on both wrists, but in fact she has two arms and one of them is perfectly functional. Operating on one wrist doesn’t automatically involve amputating the other one. Mom’s a high-maintenance nut.”

The Verdict

OP’s post about her discomfort with caring for her mother after wrist surgery highlights the delicate balance between family obligations and personal boundaries.

While some commenters emphasize self-sufficiency based on their own experiences, others question the mother’s expectations, particularly since only one wrist is affected. Meanwhile, some insightful suggestions also revealed the underlying power dynamics and potential emotional manipulation. The discussion underscores the evolving nature of caregiving and challenges traditional gender roles.

Ultimately, the comments offer diverse perspectives on striking the right balance between supporting family members and respecting individual autonomy.

What do you think? Let us know in the comments. Do you think the OP from this social media post was wrong?

Featured Image Credit: AndreyBezuglov /

This article was originally published on Ash & Pri.

Like our content? Be sure to follow us.

DISCLOSURE: The post may contain affiliate links, which means that I may receive a small commission if you make a purchase using these links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. You can read our affiliate disclosure in our privacy policy. This site is not intending to provide financial advice. This is for entertainment only.

Annika Stepanov

Annika is passionate about personal finance and travel, pouring her extensive experience into her writing on these topics. She has a diploma in Creative English Writing and has been working in the industry since 2016.