The Great Birthday Party Debate – To Invite or Not to Invite the Whole Class?

Keep smiling. Attentive girl leaning on table while blowing candles

In a world where sharing our lives on social media is common, a simple question has sparked a big debate: Should you invite the whole class to your child’s birthday party?

It all began with a heartfelt post from a concerned mother seeking validation for her decision, and the responses that followed unveiled a spectrum of opinions on this contentious matter.

The original poster (OP), a 28-year-old mom, began her story by stating that she has a wonderful 8-year-old son. She explained that last year, her son had started at a new school, which proved challenging due to the pandemic. Finances were tight for her family, a situation familiar to many. They had a lot of debt and were trying hard to pay it off.

When it came time for OP’s son’s birthday party, OP wanted to make it special, but she could only afford so much. So, she decided to invite only 5 of her son’s closest friends to the party. To ensure the other kids didn’t feel left out, OP sent cupcakes and juice boxes to school.

OP also got really creative with the party. She made different kinds of cakes and cookies, and even had a pizza-making station. The kids could also play with water guns, which sounds like a lot of fun. OP thought it would be a great day for her son and his friends. After the party, the kids couldn’t stop talking about how much fun they had. They loved the party a lot. But some of the other kids who weren’t invited felt left out.

The next week, some moms talked to OP about it. They were upset that their kids weren’t invited. OP explained that it was a small party for her son’s close friends, but they kept complaining.

Now, it’s a new school year, almost 6 months later, and OP is still getting comments about it. Feeling uncertain,OP turned to the online community to seek guidance if she did something wrong.

Who Gets an Invite?

As OP’s post went live, the social media comments echoed the varied sentiments surrounding the issue.

User zukolover96 expressed disbelief at the audacity of parents confronting OP about the guest list. The user firmly supported OP’s stance, stating that the parents’ entitlement to have their children invited was “absurd.” This comment highlighted the sense of entitlement some parents feel when it comes to their children’s invitations and how it might clash with the hosts’ preferences.

Angethorp chimed in with admiration for OP’s decision, emphasizing the value of distinctiveness.

“I wouldn’t invite the whole class either. They loved it because it was different. And if nobody’s told you of late, you’re an awesome mum ”

This perspective highlighted the significance of creativity in making a memorable celebration.

Munchkin0501, approaching the discussion from a teacher’s viewpoint, validated OP’s choice as long as the invitations were discreetly given outside the school premises. Their point highlighted the potential issues surrounding inviting specific children within the classroom environment and how it can affect dynamics and feelings.

Magaimagado contributed an interesting perspective by sharing her surprise at the uproar, highlighting that, in their experience, inviting the entire class to a party was not the norm. They attributed the complaints to a sense of entitlement and jealousy, suggesting that some parents might believe their child is entitled to every celebration.

The comment from Used-Atmosphere2422 strongly supported OP’s stance emphasizing,

“You’re not obligated to invite the whole class.”

This brief remark underscored a parent’s autonomy when determining the guest list for their child’s party.

The Verdict

OP’s decision to invite only a few of her son’s classmates to his birthday party due to financial constraints sparked a myriad of opinions. While some users supported OP, highlighting that parents shouldn’t confront her about exclusions, others believed that OP’s creativity made the celebration special. A teacher’s perspective emphasized that discreet invitations outside of school were acceptable.

Overall, there’s a consensus that parents have the right to choose, though opinions differ on whether inclusivity should be prioritized.

What do you think? Let us know in the comments. Do you think the OP from this social media post was wrong?

Featured Image Credit: Dmyrto_Z /

This article was originally published on Ash & Pri.

Like our content? Be sure to follow us.

DISCLOSURE: The post may contain affiliate links, which means that I may receive a small commission if you make a purchase using these links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. You can read our affiliate disclosure in our privacy policy. This site is not intending to provide financial advice. This is for entertainment only.

Pri Kingston

Ash & Pri are the Founders of and have spent the last decade building their way towards financial freedom and a lifetime of memories. Having successfully achieved their early retirement goal in under 10 years, they look forward to sharing their financial sense with like-minded people. Read more about Ash & Pri in the 'About Us' section.