From Judgment to Empowerment – Challenging the Notion of a ‘Colorful’ Past

Close-up portrait screaming couple looking at each other, dressed in warm knitted sweaters. Isolated gray background

In a twist of events, a young woman’s decision to return a birthday gift became a catalyst for an insightful discourse on the perception of one’s dating history.

An Expensive Gift

The original poster (OP), a 26 years old female, reveals her heartfelt intention of gifting her boyfriend, Mike, a PlayStation 5 (PS5) for his birthday.

The four years they had spent together had fostered a deep bond, making the cost of the gift inconsequential.

However, what was meant to be a joyous occasion took a dark turn when Mike’s best friend, Jessica, made a demeaning remark that struck OP to her core.

Jessica implied that OP had dated several men in the past for money, and that had helped her finance the extravagant present.

Shocked and hurt by Jessica’s comment, OP confronted Mike about the incident, seeking understanding and support.

To OP’s dismay, Mike’s responses were dismissive, adding fuel to the fire.

Insult To Injury

OP’s boyfriend not only brushed off Jessica’s comment as a harmless joke but went a step further, shaming OP for her dating history with two friends, Jake and Adam.

He labeled OP as being promiscuous and questioned her character based on her past involvements.

This hurtful exchange pushed OP to take a stand and make a decision that would reshape their relationship.

Hurt and saddened, she walked out of the party and returned the gift she had so lovingly bought for her boyfriend.

Empathy and Support

The comment section became a battleground of opinions as people rallied behind OP, challenging the notion of a “colorful” past.

Most of the commenters expressed their sentiments clearly and passionately, dissecting the situation with empathy and understanding.

WombatBeans, for instance, playfully denounced the scandalous narrative surrounding OP’s dating history, suggesting,

“Use the money to get yourself something nice.”

The user’s witty response emphasized the triviality of Mike’s judgment and urged OP to prioritize her own well-being.

Similarly, Significant_Pea_2852 also joining the user above shared their perspective in the following way:

“Sheesh, no offense but your past isn’t even that colorful! Like mild beige at best.”

Mimsie4424 joined the discussion with a fierce defense of OP’s right to make her own choices without feeling shame.

They condemned Mike’s behavior, underlining that a partner should never judge or demean someone they care about.

The user’s comment resonated deeply with users who rallied behind OP, offering words of encouragement and affirming her worth.

Resilience and Empowerment

EmpressJainaSolo joined the conversation, delving deeper into the societal pressures that perpetuate the idea of a “shameful” dating history.

The user questioned who had convinced OP that engaging in consensual relationships, one after another, was wrong or reflected poorly on her character.

EmpressJainaSolo’s insightful comment shed light on the toxic and unhealthy attitude Mike held toward OP’s dating past, encouraging her to rise above societal judgments.

SnooPets8873 also expressed confusion at the negative connotations associated with OP’s dating choices.

“What was even so wrong with what you did? You dated two guys at separate times that you didn’t know, knew each other? And that’s somehow a poor reflection on you? Bizarre. These people are not worth your time or a PS5.”

This sentiment resonated with others who viewed OP’s actions as harmless and ordinary.

Wyliecoyote22 offered a heartfelt response, reassuring OP that her past should not determine her worth.

The comment celebrated OP’s resilience and urged her not to allow individuals like Mike and his friends to make her feel unworthy.

The Verdict

The diverse range of opinions showcased the power of empathy and understanding in dismantling unfair judgment.

OP’s decision to return the PS5, although seemingly extreme to some, ultimately served as an act of self-preservation.

It became a statement against the toxicity of Mike’s attitude and an opportunity for OP to seek the love and respect she deserves.

The voices that emerged from the comments section highlighted the significance of challenging societal norms and reframing the narrative around one’s dating history.

By doing so, they promoted an environment of acceptance and support, celebrating personal growth and embracing the lessons learned along the way.

In this tale of misunderstood dating history, OP emerges as a symbol of resilience and self-worth, reminding us all that our past does not determine our present or define our future.

What do you think? Let us know in the comments. Do you think the OP from this social media post was wrong?

Featured Image Credit: Oleg.Ermak88 /

This article originally appeared on Ash & Pri.

Like our content? Be sure to follow us.

DISCLOSURE: The post may contain affiliate links, which means that I may receive a small commission if you make a purchase using these links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. You can read our affiliate disclosure in our privacy policy. This site is not intending to provide financial advice. This is for entertainment only.

Pri Kingston

Ash & Pri are the Founders of and have spent the last decade building their way towards financial freedom and a lifetime of memories. Having successfully achieved their early retirement goal in under 10 years, they look forward to sharing their financial sense with like-minded people. Read more about Ash & Pri in the 'About Us' section.