Pastor conducting Bible study with senior woman at home
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

9 things Jesus never said that people think he did

It’s true that Jesus said a lot of memorable things during His lifetime, but there are some sayings people associate with him that actually came from completely different people.

A famous saying about forgiveness

Sacred Heart of Jesus statue against cloudy blue sky. Christian religious symbol outdoors with copy space. Faith spirituality prayer worship and Catholic devotion concept for believers.
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

The line ‘Hate the sin, love the sinner’ sounds exactly like something Jesus would’ve said, and that’s probably why people associate it with him. But He didn’t say it. The truth is, the phrase comes from way after Jesus’s time. It’s from around AD 424, to be specific.

St. Augustine wrote a letter encouraging people to love others while rejecting their sins, using similar words. During the 1920s, Mahatma Gandhi used a version of the saying, too. Jesus certainly spoke about the power of forgiving people and treating others with kindness, but He never said these words exactly.

The lesson about planting seeds

Sowing lawn grass seeds by hand on prepared soil in the garden in spring
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Everyone knows how karma works. Whenever somebody gets what they deserve, you’ll probably hear someone say something like, ‘You reap what you sow,’ and they might even claim that Jesus said those words. Yes, those words really are in the Bible.

But no, they’re not from Jesus, and they actually come from the Apostle Paul in Galatians 6:7. He was writing to early Christian communities in Galatia, aka modern-day Turkey, and he was trying to encourage people to think about what they’re putting out into the world. However, Jesus did sometimes use farming metaphors, so it’s easy to see why people get confused.

A morning routine with divine approval

Smiling young woman stretching in bed after waking up at home. Healthy slow morning routine, relaxation and well-being concept. Cozy bedroom with soft natural light. Fresh start of the day
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

God prefers people who get out of bed early, apparently. The saying, ‘The Lord helps those who rise early,’ is one that many people believe Jesus said at some point in the Bible. He didn’t. In fact, this saying is a translation of an old Spanish proverb that’s been around since at least the 1500s.

It even appeared in the novel Lazarillo de Tormes. Nobody knows exactly who came up with the phrase, but we know it most certainly wasn’t Jesus. There’s nothing in the Gospels about people getting special treatment because they woke up before sunrise.

Words from a final prayer

Planet Earth in Space surrounded by Stars showing North America. This image elements furnished by NASA.
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Jesus prayed for His disciples quite a lot during His final days, and He also asked God to protect them while they continued living. In John 17, He talked about His followers as being separate from the world, and it sounds pretty close to the line, ‘Be in the world, but not of the world.’

Jesus didn’t say it exactly like that, though. He says in John 17:14–16, ‘They are not of the world, even as I am not of the world,’ and asks God not to take His followers out of the world. Sure, the meaning is similar. But the wording is wrong.

Another apostle’s famous words

shutterstock 2438856119 scaled
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

James 2:26 features a line that says, ‘Faith without works is dead,’ and it’s not hard to see why this line gets repeated so often. It just sounds so deep. The thing is, despite what some people believe, it’s not from Jesus Himself.

The line actually comes from a letter written by Jesus’s brother, James. In this section, he’s talking about how believing in God isn’t enough without actually doing good things, and it’s an argument repeated throughout the Bible.

The warning about doing nothing

Lazy girl spending day relaxing on couch and wearing loungewear
Image Credit: Shutterstock.com.

Jesus spoke an awful lot about being hard-working, and that’s probably why people associate Him with saying, ‘Idle hands are the devil’s workshop.’ He probably supported the idea. He just didn’t say it.

No, the phrase dates back to at least AD 411, when St. Jerome suggested to a young man named Rusticus that he should keep himself occupied. The phrase reappeared in 1715, too, when writer Isaac Watts wrote a children’s poem. There’s no evidence Jesus said it, though.

The invitation heard in churches

TERVUREN, BELGIUM - MARCH 13, 2017: Stained Glass in the Church of Tervuren, Belgium, depicting Jesus Christ
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Anyone who’s ever been to an evangelical church will probably recognize the saying, ‘Accept me as your personal Lord and Savior.’ Yes, a lot of pastors claim that Jesus said it. They’ll use it to encourage people to accept Jesus into their lives, although it’s not quite correct.

There’s nothing wrong with accepting Jesus, of course. It’s just that He never actually said that in the Bible. Rather, He told people to follow Him and repent, as well as believe in His teachings, but He never spoke these words. Nobody actually knows where they came from.

A promise that wasn’t made

low angle view of Jesus in robe holding rosary and reaching hand against blue sky
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

We can all agree that life isn’t always easy. Jesus supposedly promised there’s an upside to it, and He allegedly said, ‘I never said it would be easy. I only said it would be worth it.’ The saying has appeared on countless inspirational images. There’s usually Jesus’ picture next to it.

The phrase is especially popular among Latter-day Saint communities, even though it doesn’t appear in the Bible or other LDS scriptures. Interestingly, Jesus suggested the opposite idea in Matthew 11:30. He described His burden as light and His yoke as easy, so quite a different message from this one.

The promise of another opportunity

Opportunity word written on wood block. Opportunity text on table, concept.
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Fans of The Sound of Music will likely know the saying, ‘When God closes a door, he opens a window.’ Maria remembers the Reverend Mother giving her similar advice in the 1965 movie, and it’s become a pretty popular phrase.

It’s a great way to comfort someone who wants to give up. But it’s not something that Jesus said. Yes, He did talk a few times about doors when discussing opportunities, yet He never promised that God would open a window. That’s just movie magic.

Sources: Please see here for a complete listing of all sources that were consulted in the preparation of this article.

11 misunderstandings about Christianity you should stop believing

Cross over wood table with old book, holy Bible
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Some ideas about Christianity have been repeated so much that people think they’re true, but the thing is, they’re not.

11 misunderstandings about Christianity you should stop believing