Years can pass without any answers in some missing-person cases, but then, out of the blue, the person turns up alive, long after people expected them to come back.
The threat that wasn’t real
There was much more than a locked door keeping Colleen Stan captive. The 20-year-old accepted a ride from Cameron and Janice Hooker in Northern California in May 1977, but they instead took her captive. She was locked in a box under Cameron’s waterbed for 23 hours a day.
They brainwashed Colleen into thinking that an organization called ‘The Company’ would hurt her family if she escaped. She believed them. Seven years later, in 1984, Janice confessed the truth that the Company wasn’t real. Janice spoke to a church minister and encouraged Stan to leave. She did so.
A school route interrupted
11-year-old Jaycee Dugard disappeared near South Lake Tahoe, California, on June 10, 1991. She was heading toward her school bus stop when a man forced her into his car. His name was Phillip Garrido. He, along with his wife Nancy, kept Dugard a prisoner in their house. Dugard was repeatedly assaulted and had two daughters.
18 years later, in August 2009, Garrido showed up at UC Berkeley with two young girls. He was acting weirdly. So weirdly, in fact, that his parole officer told him to report in, and he went to the station with a woman. That meeting revealed that the woman was Dugard, who was now 29 years old and finally free of her captor.
A voice from Seymour Avenue
It was the day before Amanda Berry’s 17th birthday when she disappeared. The date was April 21, 2003, and Berry had just left work at a Burger King joint in Cleveland, Ohio, when she vanished. Nobody had a clue where she had gone. Turns out, she had been kidnapped by a man named Ariel Castro. The truth only came to light ten years later.
One day, Castro left home and forgot to lock one of the doors, so Berry took a chance. She screamed at the neighbors for help, and they managed to break in. Berry escaped the home with her daughter and immediately called the police, saying, ‘Help me, I’m Amanda Berry, I’ve been kidnapped, and I’ve been missing for ten years. And I’m here. I’m free now.’
The others who disappeared
One of the saddest parts of the Amanda Berry case was the fact that she wasn’t the only victim. No, Michelle Knight and Gina DeJesus were also held captive at Castro’s Seymour Avenue home. Knight disappeared on August 23, 2002, while DeJesus disappeared on April 2, 2004.
Police initially treated Knight as a runaway, so they didn’t put a lot of resources into looking for her. The two women eventually escaped with Berry when she phoned the police on May 6, 2013. Knight had been missing for over 11 years, and DeJesus for over 9 years.
Two boys walked into a police station
On March 1, 1980, a 14-year-old boy walked into a police station in Ukiah, California, with a five-year-old boy. He explained to the police that he and the younger boy had been kidnapped. The 14-year-old boy was Steven Stayner, a boy who had been abducted in Merced, California, when he was 7 years old. That was on December 4, 1972.
Kenneth Parnell had kept Steven a prisoner and called him Dennis. But when Steven started to grow older, Parnell decided to kidnap another child, a 5-year-old boy named Timmy White. Steven refused to let Timmy go through the same horrors. So, Steven waited until Parnell was at work, then fled the house and hitchhiked 40 miles away. He allegedly told the police, ‘I know my first name is Steven.’
The baby photos looked familiar
Not all people who disappeared know they’ve disappeared. Carlina White is an example of that, as she was only 19 days old when she disappeared from Harlem Hospital on August 4, 1987. She grew up in Connecticut and believed her name was Nejdra Nance. She didn’t know she was a missing child. But then, White began questioning her identity, as she looked nothing like her supposed mother, Annugetta Pettway.
Pettway couldn’t provide her with a birth certificate for medical insurance, either. White began searching missing-child website databases and found a picture of a baby that looked a lot like her. She contacted the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, which conducted a DNA test and confirmed it. She was White, now 23 years old.
An identity hidden from birth
Kamiyah Mobley went through something similar. She spent the majority of her childhood being called Alexis Manigo, without knowing that she’d actually been kidnapped shortly after birth from a Jacksonville, Florida, hospital. That was on July 10, 1998. Mobley grew up in Walterboro, South Carolina, believing she was the daughter of a woman named Gloria Williams.
Fast-forward several years, and Mobley began having major issues with Williams. She needed her Social Security card and birth certificate to apply for a job, but Williams couldn’t give them to her. An anonymous tip eventually led investigators to Williams’ house. They found 18-year-old Mobley in January 2017, and Williams was arrested.
DNA closed a 51-year gap
The case of Melissa Highsmith’s disappearance sure was a lengthy one. She was abducted from Fort Worth, Texas, in August 1971, when she was 22 months old, by a woman hired as her babysitter. Highsmith grew up under the name Melanie Walden. She had no idea she was a missing person, or that her biological parents were in the same city.
Then, an anonymous tip came through to the police about Melanie Walden in September 2022. DNA tests confirmed that she was actually Melissa. It had been 51 years since she vanished, but finally, she was reunited with her parents. The statute of limitations, however, expired on Melissa’s 38th birthday, so the abductor was never formally charged with her kidnapping.
A new identity unraveled
It’s thanks to issues with paperwork that Julian Hernandez eventually managed to come home. He was five years old when he disappeared from Vestavia Hills, Alabama, in August 2002. 13 years later, Julian struggled with his Social Security number while applying for college. He asked a school counselor to help him.
The counselor later realized that he was the missing boy and contacted the police. They used DNA testing to confirm it was him. His father, Bobby Hernandez, was arrested, as it turns out that he’d kidnapped the boy before taking him to pre-school. Police are unsure whether Julian knew he’d been missing.
A secret finally left the house
14-year-old Tanya Kach disappeared from McKeesport, Pennsylvania, in February 1996. A man named Thomas Hose, who worked as a security guard at her middle school, convinced her to move in with him. But soon after, he controlled her every movement. He manipulated her into believing that her family didn’t care about her and forced her to stay at home.
He eventually gave her more freedom, including allowing her out of the house for brief stretches of time. Kach walked into a neighborhood deli in March 2006 and told the worker who she was. They contacted the police. It had been 10 years since she went missing, but Kach was free.
The search crossed into Mexico
The main reason that Sabrina Allen’s disappearance was such a mystery was that it happened across an international border. She went missing from Texas in April 2002 when she was 5 years old, during a custody dispute between her parents. Her father, Gregory Allen, had sole custody. But her mother, Dara Llorens, refused to return Sabrina after a visit and seemed to disappear.
What really happened was that Llorens had fled to Mexico with Sabrina, feeding her daughter lies about her father. 12 years later, Mexican authorities worked with the FBI and U.S. Marshals Service to find Sabrina and her mother. They were near Mexico City. Allen was 17 and returned to the United States, where she changed her name to Fair.
One search unexpectedly found two
A bike ride completely changed Shawn Hornbeck’s life on October 6, 2002. The 11-year-old was cycling near Richwoods, Missouri, when he disappeared, with very few clues to where he’d gone. Four years passed, and there were still no signs of him. Then a 13-year-old boy named Ben Ownby vanished in January 2007, and witnesses described what they’d seen.
They said they saw a white pickup truck. That tip helped investigators, who focused on a man named Michael Devlin and searched his apartment in Kirkwood on January 12. They found Ben, as well as 15-year-old Shawn. Shawn was only around an hour away from where he’d vanished.
A cold case finally reached her
You might think a 60-year-old cold case probably wouldn’t get solved. But in the case of Audrey Backeberg, it did. She was 20 years old when she disappeared from Reedsburg, Wisconsin, in 1962 after hitchhiking with the family babysitter. Police knew she later took a bus to Indianapolis, yet that was where the trail went cold.
In 2025, Sauk County Detective Isaac Hanson decided to reopen the case, leading to an out-of-state arrest record coming to light, as well as details from genealogy research. Analyzing public records helped him to learn about a woman who matched Audrey’s details. It was her. But unlike the other cases, Audrey’s disappearance was entirely her own choice. She was never kidnapped. In fact, she was alive and safe, living in another state.
An ancestry match revived the search
In 1951, a woman lured 6-year-old Luis Armando Albino from a park in Oakland, California. She used candy to convince him to follow her. He grew up with a different family on the East Coast. But in 2020, his biological niece, Alida Alequin, took a DNA test and was matched with an unknown man. She believed it was her uncle.
She kept digging until the police and FBI joined in. They used further testing to confirm that Luis was indeed her uncle, and he reunited with his biological family a few years later. Sadly, his mother died in 2005, and his brother Roger passed away only a few months after meeting Luis again.
She walked into authorities herself
Brenda Heist’s case is one of the strangest, as she both disappeared and reappeared of her own accord. Yes, really. The 42-year-old woman dropped off her children at school in February 2002 but failed to return home. She’d left everything behind and never left a note, so police believed she’d been kidnapped. She was declared legally dead.
She turned herself in to a police station in Florida eleven years later, in April 2013. The truth was, on the day of her disappearance, she learned that her marriage was over and she was denied any housing benefits. Heist met two hitchhikers in a park and, on a whim, decided to go with them, abandoning her children and her entire original life.
Sources: Please see here for a complete listing of all sources that were consulted in the preparation of this article.
The 10 most mysterious people in history
Some of history’s most fascinating people are remembered not for what they accomplished, but for the questions they left behind.
