Anyone who’s spent enough time in a small-town diner knows they run on three things. Coffee, comfort food, & little lies. We spoke to two small-town diner servers who told us some lies that they tell. Here are twelve of them. These aren’t mean-spirited, just the kind of untruths that make their day easier. Know any others?
Featured Image Credit: Shutterstock.
“That pie is my favorite”
The pie case is likely loaded with options. But whichever one you choose is magically the owner’s personal favorite, no matter if that’s lemon meringue or chocolate cream. You’ll get an approving nod & maybe a story about how they “can’t resist it.” Yet the odds are that they’ve said the same thing to the guy two tables over. They’re just being nice.
“No rush at all”
The place is packed & the door keeps swinging. Customers are craning their necks for an open table. Yet your server is still smiling, and they assure you that there’s no rush at all. It’s not true. They’ll tell you to finish your coffee at your own pace, but they’re also secretly hoping you don’t start reading the Sunday paper cover to cover.
“Love that shirt”
It’s hard to bridge the gap between pouring water & taking your order. That’s why some servers will comment on your clothing to strike up a conversation. It could be a faded concert tee or a tractor-supply hoodie, it doesn’t matter. They’ll tell you how much they love your shirt. The truth is, it’s a simple icebreaker before the pancakes hit the grill.
“The cook made it just the way you like”
Sometimes your burger comes with a comment that the cook made it just the way you like. That’s pretty impressive. And especially so when you’ve never eaten here before. It’s diner code that they cooked it like you ordered it, but they want it to sound nicer. It makes it seem like they’ve memorized your preferences. But they haven’t.
“The cook was excited to make that”
That’s not all for food. Some servers will tell you that “the cook was excited to make that” whenever you order something. It sounds like somebody in the kitchen has been waiting all week for this moment, but really? The ticket just showed up in the queue & they made it. They’re just trying to be polite with some flattery. You might as well take it.
“I asked the kitchen to speed yours up”
Waiting too long for your omelet means that a server will likely tell you something nice. They’ll say words to the effect of, “I told the kitchen to hurry yours along.” It doesn’t really make a difference if they did or not. This is a kind little fib to ease the sting of the wait. Chances are, your ticket’s moving at the same speed as everyone else’s, but reassurance comes free.
“You didn’t have to tip”
The check is small, but you still leave a tip. Some servers will tell you that you didn’t have to leave them any money. Of course, they know most people do, yet telling them that they don’t have to makes their gratitude feel more genuine. The bill’s gone & you both move on smiling. How nice is that?
“Wish I could chat longer”
You might find the server suddenly tells you, “Wish I could chat longer.” This is diner shorthand that they have a dozen other things to do. As such, they can’t wait around. They’ll circle back later if they can. But right now, pies need slicing & coffee pots need refilling. This is the polite way of letting you know that.
“I’ll tell the owner you came by”
Cash register conversations sometimes end with this statement. The server tells you that they’ll let the owner know you stopped in. Yet whether or not that happens is anyone’s guess. Still, it wraps up the conversation in a way that you’ll feel a sense of small-town connection. Will they mention it the next time you walk in? Guess you’ll have to find out.
“You came in on the perfect day”
Nothing’s different, and they still have the same menu & same staff. They also have the same coffee brewing. But you might hear a server claiming that you came in on the perfect day. That’s not because anything specific happened. Rather, it just plants the idea that your timing was right, and they want to make you feel good about that.
“The owner says hi”
Many servers will quickly stop by your table to tell you that “the owner says hi.” It’s probably not true. In fact, the owner’s in the back filling out delivery slips, or maybe they’re not even there today. Yet this statement is a simple way to make it feel like the greeting came from the top. They’re being nice.
“That’s the order we always recommend to friends”
You’ll likely hear that your order is the one that servers “always tell friends to get.” They’re unlikely to be keeping a chart of what their friends order. Instead, they’re trying to give you a pat on the back for your choice. This turns a regular pick into something far more special than it actually is.
Like our content? Be sure to follow us.
