Banana Pudding. Classic traditional American dessert favorite. Banana Pudding, made with vanilla pudding, bananas and vanilla wafers and whipped cream.
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

12 desserts from the American South that no northerner would touch

These Southern desserts may not go over too well with your Northern friends.

Grape hull pie

Grape hull pie
Image Credit: Southern Foodways Alliance / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0).

Muscadine grapes have thick skins that are usually tossed aside when snacking on the fruit raw. Across parts of the American South, those leftover skins go into making grape hull pie.

Cooks boil the pulp off the skins, then remove the seeds and combine the cooked hulls with cooked, sweetened fruit. The result is a dark purple pie with a fruity taste and texture all its own, unlike anything you’d find in a standard grape jelly pie.

Grape hull pie is made with scuppernongs too, the bronze-skinned muscadines. Someone used to seedless grapes and velvety fruit fillings may be startled to bite into sizable stretches of grape skin in a piece of this pie.

Lane cake

Lane Cake
Image Credit: Eunice / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0).

Lane cake is perhaps Alabama’s best known traditional dessert. Emma Rylander Lane of Clayton, Alabama published this recipe in her cookbook, Some Good Things to Eat in 1898.

Mrs. Lane won a baking competition with this cake, which consists of layers of light white sponge cake filled with a rich mixture of egg yolks, butter, sugar, raisins and whiskey and covered with fluffy boiled icing. It is often made with pecans and coconut as well.

Lane cake became a featured part of most southern celebrations, especially birthdays, weddings and large family functions. Northerners who have never tried this wonderful dessert may be taken by surprise when their fork cuts into whiskey soaked fruit hidden between delicate layers of airy white cake. A mixture of raisins, liquor and sweet icing may also seem excessive to some when compared to more common layer cakes.

Coca-cola cake

chocolate brownie cake with ganache
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Often called Coca-Cola cake, this Southern classic brings one of the region’s most famous beverages right into a delicious homemade dessert. Invented in Atlanta, Georgia, Coke eventually made its way into Southern kitchens, where generations of home cooks have added it to both sweet and savory dishes.

Coca-cola cake recipes usually call for cocoa, butter, buttermilk and Coca-Cola. Many recipes also add miniature marshmallows to the batter. The cake is topped with a warm chocolate frosting made with more Coke and often finished with chopped pecans.

The cola keeps the cake moist and sweet, but you’d never end up with a dessert that tastes like soda pop.

People up North who have never had the pleasure of trying this Southern concoction may think putting cola into chocolate cake batter is disgusting. For others, the marshmallows and warm frosting poured over the cake straight from the pan might be a turnoff.

Lady Baltimore cake

Lady Baltimore cake
Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons.

Lady Baltimore cake is an old-fashioned Southern dessert that originated in Charleston, South Carolina. It became nationally known after being featured in Owen Wister’s 1906 novel titled Lady Baltimore. This book contributed to the Lady Baltimore cake becoming trendy for celebrations and other special occasions.

Figs, raisins, cherries, walnuts, and pecans are mixed with boiled icing and layered between white, airy cake layers. It is frosted with a light icing that is similar to meringue.

Because the cake already contains several dried fruits and nuts mixed into very sweet cake batter, it is richer than your traditional sponge cake.

If you are from the North and like your cake fillings to be less extravagant, the combination of raisins, figs, and nuts may surprise you with its heaviness. The sweetness from the icing may also be excessive for some people.

New Orleans pralines

New Orleans pralines
Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons.

The praline is a classic southern candy with deep connections to Louisiana Creole cuisine. European praline candy inspired cooks to make their own version of this creamy confection with local ingredients: sugar, butter and cream or milk combined with pecans, which grow wild throughout the American South.

Making pralines, the ingredients are cooked together until thickened, then poured onto a flat surface with a spoon to create oddly-shaped, flat discs. Once cooled, the result is a soft, crumbly candy.

Traditional New Orleans pralines have a creamy interior and are much softer than hard caramel candies or nuts enrobed with chocolate. They should be easy to break apart and have a buttery, sugary taste.

Once these pralines came about, they grew into a regular part of New Orleans confectionery and can still be found all over the souvenir shops in the French Quarter.

Those from the North expecting a crisp pecan brittle could be surprised at just how quickly these melt and crumble on the tongue. Assuming you can get past how sweet they are, plenty of people find the texture grainy, and it can take a while to develop a taste for them.

Southern banana pudding

Banana pudding
Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons.

Banana pudding now ranks among the most popular desserts you’ll find at Southern gatherings, church suppers, and family reunions.

It typically consists of layers of sliced bananas, vanilla custard and vanilla wafers, topped with whipped cream or baked meringue. The vanilla wafers soak up some of the moisture from the pudding as it sets, softening to a cake-like texture that compliments both the bananas and vanilla custard.

Northerners who picture banana pudding as a crunchy cookie dessert may be surprised to find out that the vanilla wafers are actually meant to absorb some of the pudding’s moisture and turn soft and spongy.

And those who prefer crunchy sweets may find banana pudding, with its ripe bananas, sweet custard and softened cookies, a bit hard to understand.

Dried peach fried pies

home made peach turnover served with slices of a fresh peach
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Fried fruit pies have been a tradition in Southern and Appalachian kitchens for generations. A hand-held fried pastry was a convenient way to make use of fruit preserved from summer harvests.

Families dried peaches to enjoy year-round, when fresh fruit was scarce. You make the pie filling by cooking dried fruit pieces down with water, sugar and spices until they’re soft and thickened. Peach filling is spooned into rounds of dough, then folded into half moons and fried until crisp, sometimes in lard.

While bakery fruit pies may have glossy, shiny filling, these fried hand pies have a thick, concentrated peach filling inside a flaky crust. Northerners raised on fresh-fruit pies may be turned off by the dark color and chewy texture of dried peach filling. And anyone new to Southern cooking might hesitate at the thought of frying a fruity dessert in animal fat.

Buttermilk chess pie

chess pie pairs a traditional butter pie crust with a sweet, custardy filling in white baking dish on concrete table, horizontal view from above, flat lay, free space
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Chess pie is perhaps the most famous dessert associated with the Southern tradition of home baking. This is a simple dessert of eggs, sugar and butter, occasionally thickened with cornmeal or flour, and it comes in many varieties.

Most chess pie recipes include buttermilk for just enough acidity to balance the custard’s sweetness. While adding a spoonful of cornmeal to dessert may sound strange, it is this ingredient that helps give the pie its texture and sets it apart from traditional cream pies.

Some Southern families have chess pie recipes that call for vinegar or other ingredients to provide the necessary acid rather than buttermilk. Those in the North who favor velvety custards and cream pies may find the somewhat gritty texture of certain cornmeal recipes off-putting. Pairing tart buttermilk with rich butter and some grain-based thickener in a sweet dish could strike newcomers as unusual too.

Sweet potato pone

Sweet potato pone
Image Credit: Ash & Pri.

Sweet potato pone is one of the oldest known dishes in Southern cuisine, including African American cuisine. Made with locally available sweet potatoes and other ingredients most pantries already had on hand, sweet potato pone is a traditional favorite among many Southerners.

Unlike the fluffy sweet potato casseroles typically served during the holidays, traditional recipes almost always call for grated raw sweet potatoes, sugar or molasses, spices, and butter. Many vintage recipes also call for lard.

This mixture is then baked slowly until the sweet potatoes are cooked through and the ingredients reach a gooey texture on the inside with a dark crust on top. Grating the potatoes rather than mashing them as you would for sweet potato pie gives you a dessert with a distinctly different texture.

Those visiting from the North who expect a light cake or a fluffy sweet potato dish might be turned away by its dense texture and gluey interior. Its color also does not allow it to look like a dessert.

Sawdust pie

Sawdust pie
Image Credit: Ash & Pri.

You’ll find sawdust pie, a regional dessert from Kentucky, at spots like Patti’s 1880 Settlement in Grand Rivers. It derives its name from the crumbly nature of its graham cracker, shredded coconut, chopped pecan, sugar and egg white filling.

When baked, it creates a brown, crumbly top with a chewy texture, and gooey interior. It is served topped with sliced bananas and whipped cream. The combination of coconut, pecans and banana is actually quite delicious.

Northerners are often taken aback when they spot it on a menu, figuring something gross must be mixed in or that it has a nasty dry texture. Those wood shaving-like crumbles on top hardly do anything to clear up the confusion.

Kentucky bourbon balls

Female making homemade rum balls candy truffles at Christmas to give as gift.
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Kentucky Bourbon Balls are a popular Southern treat that proudly shares its heritage with Kentucky bourbon production.

These candies, first made in 1938 by Ruth Hanly Booe of Rebecca Ruth Candy in Frankfort, KY, feature a creamy bourbon-flavored center, a dark chocolate coating, and a frequent topping of chopped pecan. The filling is rich, and has a strong alcohol flavor that may shock Northern newcomers expecting traditional chocolate candy.

For anyone unfamiliar with liquor-filled chocolates, the taste can come across as overpowering, or the pairing simply strange.

Southern Divinity candy

Divinity candy
Image Credit: Ejm225 / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0).

Divinity is a candy with deep roots in old-fashioned Southern home cooking.

Seen on most dessert tables around Christmas and family reunions, divinity candy is made by whipping hot sugar syrup into stiff egg whites. Once it becomes light and fluffy, chopped pecans are added. It has a melt-in-your-mouth texture, more like cotton candy than crunchy brittle or hard fudge.

Northerners unfamiliar with this candy may be turned off by its texture (and appearance) and its extreme sweetness. And when the weather turns humid, divinity just doesn’t hold up, going all sticky, gooey, or chewy.

Sources: Please see here for a complete listing of all sources that were consulted in the preparation of this article.

Like our content? Be sure to follow us.

11 holiday side dishes only the South serves

Pineapple half-moon rings holiday casserole with cranberries, crackers, almond and cheese in baking dish on concrete table, horizontal view from above, flat lay, close-up
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Southern holiday tables don’t mess around. It doesn’t matter that you might see the main dish carved up front & center because it’s the side dishes that people can’t get enough of.

11 holiday side dishes only the South serves